Sunday, October 17News That Matters

Chinese man kidnapped and killed in elaborate body-swap scheme

Chinese coffin

Traditional burials are banned in parts of China

A Chinese man with Down’s syndrome was kidnapped and killed in a bungled plot to grant another man’s wish for burial rather than cremation.

Before he died of cancer in 2017 a man from south-east China told his family he wanted a traditional burial, but in some regions these are banned.

His family hired someone to find a substitute body that could be cremated in place of their relative’s.

But unknown to them, the man they hired committed murder to provide the body.

In September 2020 the man hired by the family – identified only by his surname Huang – was given a suspended death sentence over the murder.

While the murder happened in 2017, the case only gained prominence last week after an article about the incident came to wider attention online in China.

Finding a body

Court documents show Huang had in 2017 been offered money by the family to provide them with another body as they wanted their deceased family member to have a traditional burial.

The family live in Shanwei city in Guangdong province, where the government requires all dead bodies to be cremated.

But while the family assumed he would look for another dead body, Huang killed someone in order to fulfil the deal.

Spotting a man with Down’s syndrome picking litter from the street, Huang persuaded him to get into a car and gave the victim alcohol until he passed out.

He then put the victim’s body into a coffin and days later it was passed on to the family in exchange for money.

The family paid 107,000 yuan (£11,900; $16,300), of which 90,000 yuan went to the accused while the rest went to a middleman who has since died.

Swapping the caskets

The family then proceeded to have that coffin cremated, pretending it contained the body of their own relative.

The relative’s actual body was then buried in secret in a traditional way.

Columbarium in ChinaColumbarium in China

Cremated remains are usually kept in columbarium walls

After the victim’s disappearance in 2017, he was reported as a missing person.

It took police more than two years to uncover the crime and track down the accused.

In September 2020, Huang was given a suspended death sentence, which he appealed against.

This was eventually dismissed by the Guangdong Higher People’s Court in December 2020 and a suspended death sentence was upheld. This means that if he does not reoffend after two years, the sentence will be commuted to life in prison.

The family who hired Huang were found guilty of “insulting a corpse”, but were not handed a prison sentence. It is unclear if they had to instead pay a fine.

Last week a news outlet published a feature with the victim’s family, giving the story a national platform.

China’s campaign against burials

A traditional burial is favoured in China, with people investing heavily in funerals and coffins, believing that doing so is a way of showing filial piety towards their ancestors.

But China has increasingly been campaigning for people to refrain from burying their dead and in some regions there is an outright ban on burials.

This is intended to save land and discourage extravagant burial ceremonies.

A regulation dating back to 1997 stipulates that “densely populated regions with relatively little land and convenient transport should practise cremation”.

“Those regions which cannot meet such requirements are allowed to conduct burials,” the regulation says.

Body swapping is not unheard of in China, and mostly occurs in rural areas where more people put stress on following traditional burial ways.